Filter Technology
There are many methods and technologies used to clean the air you breathe. Many terms sound alike and manufacturer specifications and claims can be very confusing and sometimes misleading. We will “clear the air” about these different types of filtration to help you make an informed decision about the type of air cleaner that will work best for your specific needs. We will also provide information on each of the several types of filtration, the efficiency level, benefits and drawbacks of each.
Key Factors To Consider:
Efficiency
Filters are often rated at a percentage (i.e. 99% effective). The important factor is the particle size the filter is capable of removing from the air. Particle size is measured in microns (1/24,500th of an inch). Common particles include allergens, dander, dust, and bacteria that range from 10 microns to .01 microns (shown in table below). A 99% efficient filter may only be efficient on particles 6 microns or larger. Carefully choose a filter based on your specific needs.
Air Movement
Air movement rate, measured in cubic feet per minute (cfm), is an important factor to consider. Effective air cleaners should have enough capacity to clean a room at least 2 – 4 times each hour. Even the most efficient filter does little good if it doesn’t move all the air in a room through the filter. A 20’ by 20’ work or living space can efficiently and effectively be cleaned by a model with a 210–275 cfm rating.
Technology or Filtration Type
The technology or filtration method you are considering is important based on the pollutants you wish to remove from the air. The following chart explains more about the different technologies along with key benefits and drawbacks of those filtration types. See the definitions of these technologies under the chart below.
Technology
|
Efficiency Range
|
Particle Size
|
Advantages
|
Disadvantages
|
Fiberglass Media
|
3 – 5%
|
0.3 – 1 micron
|
Inexpensive
|
Very low efficiency
|
Electrostatic Media (No electric charge)
|
15 – 30%
|
0.3 – 1 micron
|
Relatively inexpensive Some use washable filters |
Efficient only on larger particles Some require replacement filters |
Electret Media (Electrically charged)
|
40 – 90%
|
0.3 – 1 micron
|
High efficiency on large-medium size particles
|
Low efficiency on smaller particles
|
Medium Efficiency Media
|
35 – 60%
|
0.3 – 1 micron
|
Low airflow resistance
|
Require replacement filters
|
High Efficiency Media
|
60 – 95%
|
0.3 – 1 micron
|
High efficiency on many smaller particles
|
High airflow resistance Require replacement filters |
HEPA Media
|
99.7%
|
0.3 – 1 micron
|
High efficiency on many smaller particles
|
High airflow resistance Require replacement filters |
Ozone Generator
(emission of the highly reactive molecute-O3) |
inconclusive testing information
|
0.3 – 1 micron
|
Ideal for removing odor after fires
|
No particle collection May irritate asthma Considered dangerous by the EPA and OSHA |
Ionizer
(negatively charged ions) |
inconclusive testing information
|
0.3 – 1 micron
|
Relatively low cost
|
No particle collection Larget particles may be |
Electrostatic Precipitator
|
Up to 97%
|
0.01 microns
|
High efficiency on many smaller particles Washable and reusable filters |
Filter must be maintained Dirty filter decreases efficiency |
Air Purification Terms
Media Filters – are commonly made from cotton or synthetic woven materials. The filter fibers catch particulates as air is pulled in by the circulating fan. Higher efficiency filters produce higher airflow resistance. Tightly woven filters capture more (and smaller) particulate but also allow less airflow. As more particles are captured in the filter, airflow resistance increases. As a result, Media filters must be changed regularly to maintain optimum efficiency.
Electrostatic Media – is prone to static charge. These filters, usually made from plastic fibers, generate a static charge as friction is generated by airflow. Electrostatic media is generally loosely woven allowing for low airflow resistance, but has lower efficiency on smaller particulates as a result. Electrostatic media filters must be changed or cleaned regularly to maintain system efficiency.
Electret Media – is the same concept as electrostatic media, but is charged prior to installation. These filters obtain a moderate efficiency on smaller particles than the electrostatic media. Electret media filters must be changed or cleaned regularly to maintain system efficiency.
Ozone Generators – do not utilize filters. These machines emit highly reactive Ozone (O3) molecules into the air to dissipate airborne pollutants. An ozone generator is considered to be a hazardous workplace chemical by OSHA and is considered an air pollutant by the EPA. Ozone may also be harmful to individuals with asthma.
Ionizers – also do not use filters but operate on electrostatic attraction. The unit emits negatively charged ions from a needle-like point that attach themselves to airborne particles. They are then attracted to positively charged items or surfaces such as wall and furnishings.
Electrostatic Precipitators – operate using electrostatic attraction to collect particles to a filter cell. The collection plates within the filter cell are charged alternately charged with positive and negative ionizing wires. This allows for low airflow resistance while remaining highly effective on small airborne particles. Electrostatic air cleaners become less effective as the filter cell collects these particles. The electronic collecting cell must be cleaned regularly to maintain maximum efficiency.